Profit.ly alternative
Profit.ly costs roughly $30-$75 per month. TradeStack covers the same daily journaling loop — broker CSV import, a daily P&L calendar, win rate, profit factor, expectancy, playbooks and prop firm rule tracking — for free.
Why traders look for an alternative
The usual reason is simple: the focus is proving trades to an audience, not analysing your own edge — and the useful analytics sit behind paid tiers. Journaling only helps if you do it every session for months, and paying monthly before the habit exists is what makes most traders quit after week three.
What Profit.ly is genuinely good at
Credit where it is due: trade verification and a large community of penny stock traders. This page is not arguing that the tool is bad. If that capability is the core of your process and the price is not an issue, stay where you are.
Side by side
| Feature | Profit.ly | TradeStack |
|---|---|---|
| Price | roughly $30-$75 per month | Free |
| Broker CSV import | Yes | Yes, 20+ formats auto-detected |
| Daily P&L calendar | Yes | Yes, with the dollar result on each day |
| Win rate, profit factor, expectancy | Yes | Yes |
| Playbooks / setups | Usually paid tier | Free, with multi-playbook tagging |
| Prop firm rule tracking | Limited | Daily loss, drawdown and consistency % |
| Trade limit | Plan dependent | Unlimited |
Pricing and features of other tools change often — check their site for current terms.
How to switch in five minutes
- Export your trade history from Profit.ly or directly from your broker as CSV.
- Create a free TradeStack account — no card, no trial countdown.
- Import the file; the column layout is detected for you.
- Check the calendar and analytics, then keep importing weekly.
Frequently asked
Is TradeStack really free compared with Profit.ly?
Yes. There is no paid tier, no trade cap and no trial timer. Analytics, imports, playbooks and the calendar are all included.
What does Profit.ly do better?
Trade verification and a large community of penny stock traders. If that specific thing is central to your process, it may still be worth the cost.
Can I move my history across?
Yes. Export your trades as CSV from your current tool or straight from your broker and import the file — the layout is detected automatically.
Which brokers are supported?
Tradovate, NinjaTrader, Rithmic, MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, Interactive Brokers, TradeStation, thinkorswim, Webull, tastytrade, Binance, Bybit and more.